Is Bra bondage for women, or a liberation?
First of all if you think about it from a health perspective. Compared to the obvious health damage caused by high heels and tight corsets, here’s the problem: wearing a bra correctly will certainly be beneficial to your health. Although, not wearing a bra correctly can be more harmful than not wearing one at all. But not wearing a bra is certainly more harmful than wearing it correctly. Bras act as support and protection, and their positive effects on breast health are immeasurable. And, of course, shaping. This brings us back to the “philosophical question”. Feminists will jump in and say: “It’s a straitjacket for women.
Clothing can become a form of power, and even underwear can become an instrument of oppression. — ‘Lingerie: A Cultural History’ Steele
There are a couple of myths about going braless that do not have any scientific backing:
Millennial women appear to be ditching the traditional bra by purchasing wireless bralettes or not wearing the undergarment at all.
Retailers such as Victoria’s Secret are reporting declining sales for bras, according to an article in USA Today.
There was even a national No Bra Day last week.
The growing trend has renewed debate over whether losing the bra has any health effects.
The answer appears to be that, as far as health goes, it doesn’t appear to make much difference whether you wear a bra or not.
“We don’t have any evidence that says going braless hurts you,” Patricia Geraghty, a nurse practitioner in California who specializes in women’s health, told Healthline.
One of the few research projects to provide any kind of conclusion was a 15-year study completed in 2013 by Jean-Denis Rouillon, a professor in France.
In his research, he concluded bras provide no benefits to women and might actually be harmful to breasts over time.
Rouillon said his study involving 300 women ages 18 to 35 showed that women who did not wear bras developed more muscle tissue to provide natural support.
He added that the restrictive material of bras prevents tissue from growing and may actually encourage breasts to sag.
Rouillon did caution women who have worn bras for decades not to throw out their undergarments. He said they would not benefit from taking off their bras at this juncture.
Otherwise, there isn’t any substantial research either way on bras and breast health.
The American Cancer Society states there is no scientific evidence to show that wearing a bra increases or decreases the risk of breast cancer.
In 1999, there was a studyTrusted Source in Australia on breast pain and breast movement involving women who wore fashion bras, sports bras, crop tops, and no bras.
However, that study dealt more with comfort than any health effects.
Geraghty said one problem is that it’s difficult to do long-term studies on the topic.
She said researchers would have to follow women for decades who wore bras and ones who didn’t.
Even interviewing older women about their personal histories would require taking other potential risk conditions into account.
In the 1960s, some researchers coined the term “Cooper’s droop” for the sagging of the breasts they said occurred when women went braless for an extended period of time.
The name came from the Cooper’s ligaments that help hold up the breast.
The research coincided with a campaign by women’s rights activists for women to go braless. That movement, however, was politically motivated as opposed to health related.
The Cooper’s droop theory has fallen out of favor.
In fact, Geraghty said, research has shown that sagging breasts in older age don’t appear to be linked to bras or even breast-feeding.
She said it’s probably more closely linked to the number of pregnancies a woman has and how far apart those births were.
Geraghty said going braless is really more a fashion statement than a health matter. She noted that the restrictive clothing of the 1800s was probably more harmful to health.
“Fashion doesn’t much have a basis in health,” she said.
Magazine articles this year have touted the benefits of not wearing a bra. However, the reasons don’t have anything to do with health.
A Good Housekeeping article in June listed 12 reasons for going braless.
Among the benefits were showing off your natural chest, saving money by not buying bras, the absence of bra “pressure lines,” and that “just took my bra off” feeling you can have all day long.
Myth 1: Going braless promotes sagging
One myth about going braless is that the breasts will sag without a bra for support.
Many factors can lead to sagging breasts, including:
- genetics
- weight
- the natural aging process
However, there is not enough scientific evidence to suggest that going braless will cause the breasts to sag.
Myth 2: Going braless reduces the risk of breast cancer
Another myth about going braless is that it could reduce a person’s risk of developing breast cancer.
This myth is based on the idea that wearing a bra affects lymphatic drainage, which is the process that helps remove toxins and waste products from the body. A problem with lymphatic drainage can cause these substances to accumulate in the bloodstream, potentially increasing a person’s risk of developing cancer.
According to the American Cancer Society, there is no scientific evidence to associate wearing a bra with breast cancer. They note that a 2014 studyTrusted Source of 1,513 postmenopausal women found no link between wearing a bra and breast cancer risk.
This myth may stem from the fact that people with overweight tend to have larger breasts and are, therefore, more likely to wear a bra. Having overweight or obesity is a known risk factor for developing breast cancer.
According to an older study from 2000, wearing a bra or other tight fitting garment at night could affect a person’s sleep-wake cycle.
The researchers found that nighttime pressure from tight fitting garments caused an increase in core body temperature and a decrease in melatonin. Melatonin is a hormone that helps regulate the sleep-wake cycle. A decrease in melatonin can affect sleep quality.
This small scale study monitored 10 participants over a 58-hour period. Further research involving more participants and a longer study duration is necessary to support the findings.
There is no scientific evidence to suggest that wearing a correctly fitting bra during the day has any negative effects on health.
However, a bra that does not fit properly can cause pain in the neck and the chest muscles.
Excessively tight shoulder straps may also affect the shoulders. In those who wear a bra, the shoulder straps are one of the main supports for the breasts. Over several years, this tension may cause a permanent groove in the soft tissue of the shoulders.
There may also be a link between wearing a badly fitting bra and seeking breast reduction surgery. A 2003 study found that of 102 females undergoing this procedure, all of them had been wearing the wrong size of bra. Wearing a badly fitting bra may worsen the symptoms that cause people to seek breast reduction surgery.
The researchers concluded that people should ensure that they are wearing a correctly fitting bra before considering getting surgery to reduce the size of their breasts.
Going braless or wearing the wrong size of bra may be a barrier to exercise for some people. A lack of exercise can cause a range of health issues.
In a 2013 survey of 249 females, 17% reported that their breasts were a barrier to exercise. Some of the key reasons for this included:
- embarrassment over excessive breast movement
- being unable to find the right sports bra
- increase in breast pain due to vigorous exercise and a lack of adequate breast support
The researchers noted that better knowledge of breast health led to increased use of a sports bra, resulting in increased exercise levels among the participants.
When choosing a sports bra, people should look for options that provide the greatest support. A 2015 studyTrusted Source investigated the effects of wearing a sports bra during running. The findings suggest that sports bras that offer a high level of support can reduce breast pain, particularly for people with larger breasts.
Sports medicine specialist Prof. Jean-Denis Rouillon carried out a 15-year study to assess whether bras cause sagging. The study involved 330 females aged 15–35 years.
Rouillon’s findings suggested that wearing a bra can weaken the chest muscles, thereby promoting sagging. Rouillon concluded that going braless encourages the chest muscles to work harder to elevate the breasts.
There is no official published study of Rouillon’s findings and no peer review. As such, it is not possible to evaluate the validity of the research.
Marco Klinger, Head of the Operating Unit of Plastic Surgery at Humanitas Research Hospital in Italy, states that the study is too small to be an accurate representation of breast sagging in the general population.
According to Klinger, a wide range of variables are likely to affect breast sagging. These include:
- aging
- genetics
- changes in weight
- normal hormonal phases
- pregnancy
Overall, there is not enough scientific evidence to suggest that either wearing a bra or going braless has any effect on sagging.
However, for people with larger breasts, supporting the connective tissues of the breasts by wearing a bra may help reduce the rate of sagging.
According to a 2013 study, large breasts are associated with the following symptoms:
Many people with large breasts claim that their breasts are the cause of their back pain. However, according to the Women’s Health Research Institute of Northwestern University, even large breasts are rarely the primary cause of back pain.
Instead, back pain may be due to:
- wearing a badly fitting bra
- having overweight or obesity
- injury to the back muscles
- irritation of the spinal nerves
- osteoporosis, or weakening of the spine
- pregnancy
Wearing a correctly fitting bra may help improve posture and prevent back pain, particularly for people with larger breasts.
People who continue to experience back pain should see a doctor. Chronic back pain could indicate an underlying health issue.
There is not enough scientific evidence to confirm whether or not wearing a bra or going braless can cause the breasts to sag or change shape.
There is also insufficient evidence to suggest that wearing a correctly fitting bra has negative effects on health. In fact, people with larger breasts may find that wearing a correctly fitting bra improves their posture and reduces back pain. In contrast, wearing the wrong size of bra may cause pain and discomfort.